Actually we (Hville and I) came up with this a couple weeks ago, but I forgot to post it.
PG- Antoine Pettway (the best PG we've under CMG)
SG- Mo Williams (the 3rd best PG, but probably the best overal G)
SF- Rod Grizzard (when he was hot he carried the team)
PF- Erwin Dudley (the hardest working player under CMG)
PF- Chuck Davis (the 2nd hardest working player under CMG)
SG- Earnest Shelton (edges out Meade due to his clutchness)
PG- Ronald Steele (agree with this year defining him)
SF- Kennedy Winston (if he stayed another year...)
PF- Richard Hendrix (a more athletic Dudley, yet not quite as good... yet)
C- Jermareo Davidson (only because Kenny Walker had the worst hands I ever saw)
PG- Antoine Pettway (ain't nothin' but a winner!)
SG- Mo Williams (even though he played point, he really was an SG)
SF- Kennedy Winston
PF- Chuck Davis
C/F- Erwin Dudley (my favorite player under CMG)
PG- Ronald Steele (his senior year is very important to his legacy)
SG- Ernest Shelton (this has been CMG's Achilles heal his entire tenure. It's not going to take much for Justin Tubbs to better the success of Terrance Meade or Travis Stinnett)
SF- Emmett Thomas (more consistent than Grizzard and Alonzo Gee, which vanished when SEC play started this season)
PF- Richard Hendrix (Gerald Wallace played out of position in college, and only for 1 year)
C/F- Kenny Walker (One of the best FT shooting big men I have seen. Jermareo Davidson barely gets edged out. I think Jemison is primed to be as good as some of our other PFs)
We agree on 4 of 5 first team and 3 of 5 2nd team.
Hville also added a biggest bust team (which I can't disagree with).
G- Ray George (signed him twice, never made it on campus)
G- Glen Miles
SF- Albert Weber (Schea Cotton and Justin Jonus get honorable mention)
PF- Rodney Bias (signed him twice, never made it on campus)
C/F- Akini Adkins (Shawn Taylor a close second)
As I was posting this I thought of Verice Cloyd. While I don't think he's a bust per se, there was a lot of hoopla about him getting in... and after all that trouble he leaves after a year.